Appeal: direct answer
From Jay Dyer vs Mike Lowry Urantia Debate: Christianity vs Urantianism.
- #13581:33:13upheld Jay Dyer epainos: direct answer (+1)
The council upheld the call: Jay Dyer earned 1 point.
“… yes, we recognize that there's truth outside the church. Right? There there's truth in other religions. ... But what I'm saying specifically about what we understand deification to be is that, no, that's not possible outside of the God man's body.”
Diogenes: Jay concedes what he can — truth exists outside his church — and then answers the hypothetical with a reason rather than dismissing it, explaining why on his definition the scenario is not merely false but incoherent.- Aristotle uphold: On the record: S1 has held since early in the debate (e.g., his description of Eucharist as "the deified flesh of Christ. It's only in our church") that deification is sacramentally tied exclusively to the Orthodox Church's mysteries; this answer is consistent with, not a departure from, that standing position. Mike's thought experiment directly asked whether deification found possible outside the church would change Jay's beliefs; Jay answers plainly, first conceding a distinct point (truth exists outside the church) and then giving a direct reasoned answer to the specific question asked (deification, on his Christological/sacramental definition, cannot occur apart from union with Christ's body) — this is a genuine direct answer, not evasion.
- Socrates uphold: Read blind, found "direct answer". Rather than either flatly denying truth exists elsewhere (which would be an easy overreach) or conceding the thought experiment wholesale, Dyer draws a clean distinction: general truth can be found outside the church, but deification specifically is defined, within his own paradigm, as participation in Christ's deified humanity via the sacraments, so it cannot occur apart from it. This directly answers Mike's probing question and keeps his position falsifiable, as he goes on to affirm moments later ("if that's the case... Orthodoxy is not true").
- Plato uphold: On the record: Jay has held since the outset that Orthodoxy is the exclusive locus of correct theology and sacramental life, and this answer is consistent with and elaborates that standing position rather than departing from it. Mike's thought experiment asked whether finding deification possible outside the Orthodox Church would change what Jay believes; Jay answers directly, distinguishing "truth outside the church" (which he affirms) from the specific mechanism of deification (which he denies is possible outside the church) and gives the reason (deification requires sacramental union with the deified body of Christ). This is a reasoned, on-point answer to the question actually asked.
Appeal this callout
Appeals come only from the debaters themselves. Sign in with Google to start; you'll then prove which debater you are, once.