Appeal: direct answer
From @deanwithrs Gets DESTROYED In Heated Debate On God Then RUNS.
- #19224:32upheld Dean Withers epainos: direct answer (+1)
The council upheld the call: Dean Withers earned 1 point.
“What is the ontology of logic? When you asked me about the ontology of so it's a it's a plainness [Platonist] object…”
Diogenes: Asked the ontology of logic, he gives one (logic as an abstract Platonic object) while being talked over.- Aristotle uphold: On the record: S1 has held since the opening that logic is Platonic-realist abstract object (not merely a concept, no ontological grounding needed in God); here, amid heavy interruption, he responds to the repeated "what is the ontology of logic" question with "it's a Platonist object" — a direct, substantive answer consistent with his declared metaphysics, not a departure from it. The question "what is the ontology of logic" was put multiple times in the preceding exchange, and this line gives a one-word-category answer (Platonic/abstract object) that matches his stated framework; despite the crosstalk and his pivot to counter-argument immediately after, the quoted clause does answer the question actually asked.
- Socrates uphold: Read blind, found "direct answer". S0 has asked twice, "What is the ontology of logic?" and here Dean gives a specific, substantive answer — "it's a platonic object" — rather than deflecting; he then tries to move on to explain S0's error, but the question itself is answered plainly.
- Plato uphold: On the record: Dean's position of record includes Platonic realism about the laws of logic as an abstract object; when repeatedly pressed on "what is the ontology of logic," saying "it's a Platonic object" is a direct answer consistent with and specifying that stated framework, not a departure from it. S0 asked the ontology question multiple times and here S1 supplies a substantive answer (Platonic/abstract object existing outside the causal chain) rather than deflecting; this is a direct answer to the question actually on the table, even though talked over immediately after.
Appeal this callout
Appeals come only from the debaters themselves. Sign in with Google to start; you'll then prove which debater you are, once.