Appeal: direct answer
From Jay Dyer vs Yaron Brook Debate TAG, Science, and the Future of Civilization.
- #196827:07upheld Jay Dyer epainos: direct answer (+1)
The council upheld the call: Jay Dyer earned 1 point.
“Correct.”
Diogenes: Asked whether his whole system rests on the presupposition that God exists, Jay says yes without hedging and then states the parallel he means.- Aristotle uphold: On the record: Jay has held since his opening that logic and reasoning are grounded in God as the transcendental precondition, and moments before this exchange he explicitly said "logic itself is grounded in God"; when Yaron then asks directly whether the entire system is built on the presupposition that God exists, Jay's unhedged "Correct" is a direct answer to a direct question, fully consistent with his standing position. The question was put plainly and Jay answered it plainly and truthfully relative to his own stated framework; this is textbook direct answer, not a restatement dressed up as one, since a specific question was asked and specifically answered.
- Socrates uphold: Read blind, found "direct answer". Yaron asks Jay a pointed, closed question — "So the entire system is built on a presupposition that there is a God?" — and Jay answers with a single unhedged word, "Correct," rather than deflecting or qualifying. This is consistent with his stated epistemic-holist framework (God at the center of his web of belief, per 44:37), so it is an honest direct answer rather than a self-contradiction or concession of error.
- Plato uphold: On the record: Jay Dyer declared at the opening and held throughout that his ethics/logic are grounded in God as the transcendental foundation (a "web of belief" centered on God); asked point-blank whether his entire system rests on the presupposition that God exists, "Correct" is a direct, unhedged answer consistent with that standing position. This is a genuine question-answer pair (Yaron's "So the entire system is built on a p[re]suppo[si]tion that there is a God?" answered plainly with "Correct"), and it accurately reflects Jay's declared framework rather than departing from it; a minor direct answer is the right call.
Appeal this callout
Appeals come only from the debaters themselves. Sign in with Google to start; you'll then prove which debater you are, once.