Appeal: steelman
From HEATED Debate w/ Feminists. Wage Gap, Pro Choice ft. @MikeRashidOfficial.
- #20021:35:25upheld Mike Rashid epainos: steelman (+1)
The council upheld the call: Mike Rashid earned 1 point.
“I mean, I guess it's not really waiting. You know, it just took... Y'all got around to it thirteen years later because y'all was both doing y'all thing.”
Diogenes: Mike sits on the hosts' side but restates Penelope's clarification in its most charitable form: the man wasn't waiting, both of them were living their own lives. He also allows that "we don't know his side" and that "it would be fair to hear both sides", recognising the limits of the evidence instead of pressing the hosts' reading.- Aristotle uphold: On the record: Mike's position throughout the "thirteen years" exchange has been more measured than Myron/Fresh's, repeatedly noting "we don't know his side" and that it would be fair to hear both accounts; this line continues that pattern by restating Penelope's own framing charitably before questioning it further. Mike accurately restates Penelope's actual claim — that it wasn't "waiting" but two people living their own lives who eventually reconnected — in its most charitable form, matching her own account (94:00-94:20), before going on to press her further about her reasons for rejecting the man. This is a genuine steelman, not a strawman or mere agreement.
- Socrates uphold: Read blind, found "steelman". Mid-sentence, Mike catches himself repeating the hosts' reductive "he waited thirteen years" framing and corrects it to match what Penelope actually described — that both of them were dating other people and simply "got around to it" later — a more accurate and charitable restatement of her account than the one Myron and Fresh have been running with throughout the segment.
- Plato uphold: On the record: Mike Rashid has not declared a fixed framework like the hosts; throughout the debate he has repeatedly offered more even-handed, charitable readings of the women's positions (e.g. "I understand what she's saying" re: the club/bar exchange) even while generally sitting on the hosts' side, and this line is consistent with that pattern rather than a departure from it. The quote accurately and charitably restates Penelope's own clarification from 82:15 ("Didn't make him wait... he did his thing... we were both doing our thing") in Mike's own words before he goes on to add a qualification ("we don't know his side"), which is a genuine steelman-then-engage move rather than a strawman or mere agreement.
Appeal this callout
Appeals come only from the debaters themselves. Sign in with Google to start; you'll then prove which debater you are, once.