Appeal: appeal to popularity
From HEATED Debate w/ Feminists. Wage Gap, Pro Choice ft. @MikeRashidOfficial.
- #20041:39:14upheld Myron Gaines psogos: appeal to popularity (+1) tempered from minor to minor
The council upheld the call: Myron Gaines gave away 1 point.
“Yeah. It it it just can't be done because one party almost always... One party.”
Diogenes: Fresh reads out the Twitch poll result ("can women and men be friends? Answer is no, 92%"). Myron takes it straight up as confirmation, "Yeah. It just can't be done," in reply to Penelope's specific account of a work-based friendship, as if a vote by his own audience settled the question.Herodotus (partly): The site's own ledger shows Myron Gaines has two prior debates here with faults upheld for ad hominem x2, appeal to authority x2, hasty generalisation x2, motte-and-bailey x1, and tu quoque x1 — a documented habit of leaning on unearned shortcuts (authority, generalisation) rather than argument, which makes this appeal-to-popularity callout consistent with his broader style. However, no prior appeal-to-popularity fault has been upheld against him specifically, so this looks like a new variant of an old habit rather than a repeat of the identical fault. External searches turned up only general characterizations of his campus "debates" as unrigorous or misinformation-heavy (e.g. student press pieces), not a documented prior instance of citing a poll/crowd vote as proof; nothing found rises above op-ed-level commentary. Given the callout itself is already marked minor and the quote is a brief aside ("Yeah... it just can't be done") rather than the crux of his argument, the history supports tempering rather than escalating severity. Sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fresh_and_Fit_Podcast https://www.hercampus.com/school/ucf/hate-disguised-as-debate-why-myron-gaines-campus-tour-demands-a-real-response/ https://americanbazaaronline.com/2025/11/25/who-is-myron-gaines-controversial-podcaster-at-center-of-akaash-singh-viral-feud-470562/
- Aristotle uphold: On the record: Myron's declared and consistently held method throughout is to assert generalizations about women as settled fact, often propped up by an appeal to some external validator (unnamed studies, "biologically proven," Jordan Peterson) rather than engaging individual testimony directly; here the validator is his own audience's Twitch poll, cited by Fresh and affirmed by Myron with "Yeah" before he continues into his standing thesis. Myron's "Yeah. It just can't be done" comes directly on the heels of Fresh reading the 92% poll result and treats that crowd vote as confirming the point rather than as mere color, which is the appeal-to-popularity move; the fault is properly minor since he immediately pivots to supplying his own (separately flawed) reasoning rather than resting on the poll alone.
- Socrates uphold: Read blind, found "hasty generalisation", on the same ledger as the callout. Fresh reads off a Twitch poll of the show's own self-selected, sympathetic audience (92% said no), and Myron simply says "Yeah" and restates his standing thesis — "one party almost always... usually the man wants the woman and the woman friend-zones him" — as flat fact, with no evidence beyond the in-house poll and his own repeated assertion, matching the same unsupported "it's usually/always X between men and women" pattern already flagged at 54:32, 54:52, and 55:36.
- Plato overturn: On the record: Myron's declared framework since early in the debate is to argue the no-platonic-friendship thesis from his own stated reasoning (the "backdoor route to sex" theory, "men want sex, women want attention"), a position he had already built at length before this poll was ever read; the poll is Fresh's own aside about the audience, not a premise Myron introduces. Fresh reads out the Twitch poll as audience commentary; Myron's "Yeah, it just can't be done" is followed immediately not by resting on the 92% figure but by his own already-established reasoning ("one party almost always... the man wants the woman... men want sex, women want attention"), which is a restatement of the thesis he has been arguing throughout rather than a substitution of crowd agreement for argument — the poll functions as color, not as his cited proof.
Appeal this callout
Appeals come only from the debaters themselves. Sign in with Google to start; you'll then prove which debater you are, once.