Appeal: explicit argument
From HEATED Debate w/ Feminists. Wage Gap, Pro Choice ft. @MikeRashidOfficial.
- #20302:01:14upheld Penelope epainos: explicit argument (+1)
The council upheld the call: Penelope earned 1 point.
“Men can get women pregnant every single time that they have sex and ejaculate. Women can only get pregnant like two three days of the month. So it's really, I feel up to the men to make sure…”
Diogenes: Penelope answers Myron with a stated counter-argument: male fertility is continuous and female fertility is cyclical, so men carry the greater share of responsibility for preventing conception. It is a premise-and-conclusion rebuttal aimed at the conception stage, which his argument leaves out.- Aristotle uphold: On the record: Penelope's position of record is that responsibility for conception is shared between man and woman, and she has held this since the abortion/contraception exchange began, repeatedly countering Myron's "it's the woman's choice, therefore the woman's sole responsibility" framing. The line states a biological premise (continuous male fertility vs. a narrow female fertile window) and draws a conclusion (men bear significant responsibility for preventing conception) directly rebutting Myron's just-prior claim that responsibility runs entirely to the woman; this reinforces rather than departs from her "shared responsibility" position and meets the bar for premises-and-conclusion argument, matching the standard already applied to Myron's mirror-image argument at 121:01.
- Socrates uphold: Read blind, found "explicit argument". Against Myron's claim that pregnancy is entirely a female choice and responsibility, Penelope lays out plain premises — men can cause pregnancy at every ejaculation, women are fertile only a few days a month — and draws the conclusion that follows: contraceptive responsibility should fall on the man. It directly rebuts the argument on the table rather than dodging or asserting a mere feeling.
- Plato uphold: On the record: Penelope's position throughout the pregnancy exchange has been that conception is a shared responsibility ("it's a 50/50... choice... between a man and a woman," 120:26-121:00) rather than solely the woman's as Myron claims; this line elaborates that position with a stated premise (continuous male fertility vs. cyclical female fertility) supporting why men bear a large share of the practical burden of prevention, which is consistent with, not a departure from, her recorded stance. The quote states a clear premise (men can impregnate at any sexual encounter, women are fertile only a few days a month) leading to a stated conclusion (the onus falls more heavily on men to prevent conception), offered directly in response to Myron's claim that pregnancy is entirely the woman's choice/responsibility; this is a genuine premises-to-conclusion rebuttal, not mere assertion.
Appeal this callout
Appeals come only from the debaters themselves. Sign in with Google to start; you'll then prove which debater you are, once.