Appeal: correcting the record
From Ryad TRIGGERS Miami Girls After Saying THIS... 2026-10-19 22:20.
- #26151:10:31upheld S25 epainos: correcting the record (+1)
The council upheld the call: Speaker 25 earned 1 point.
“At the beginning of show, you said if he tells his [you to] shut up, you wouldn't do it…” quote corrected
Diogenes: S23 asked "Did I not say I was gonna obey my boyfriend? I literally said I do"; the record at 32:56 shows she answered "No, actually" when asked if she would be quiet if told "silence," and S25 states what she said instead.minor: The label is always minor, so the grade does not raise it; the correction is accurate to the transcript.
- Aristarchus (transcript) corrected: "his" is plainly "you to" (tells you to shut up), as S28 at 70:12 refers to "the shut up part" and the sentence needs an addressee; the missing "the" before "show" is left alone as a possible speaker slip.
- Aristotle uphold: On the record: S25 declared nothing at the opening; he joined late among the men pressing the girls on obedience and headship, and he has held that a woman should obey her man. The called line, a correction of what S23 had said earlier, fits that position and does not depart from it. S23 asked "when did I not say I was gonna obey my boyfriend?" At 32:56 she had answered "No, actually" when asked if she would be quiet if told "silence." S25 states what the record has in its place, and the verifier confirms it. "At the beginning of show" is loose timing, but the substance is right and checkable. The correction is aimed at the point in dispute, not at mocking her, so it stands as a minor correction of the record.
- Socrates uphold: Read blind, found "correcting the record". S23 had just asked "when did I not say I was gonna obey my boyfriend?" The record bears S25 out: at 32:56 she answered "No, actually" to whether she'd be quiet if told silence, and at 33:03 she said "he wouldn't either". "Beginning of show" is loose, since it was about 33 minutes in, but the substance is right and checkable. It is a minor correction that fixes the point and does not mock her.
- Plato uphold: On the record: S25 declared no thesis at the opening (S1 spoke there); he joined later as a supporter of the men's side, holding that women should obey. The called line only checks what S23 said earlier, so it does not depart from that. S23 asked when she had ever said she would not obey. S25 answered with what she said earlier, and the verifier confirmed it: at 32:56 she said "No, actually" when asked if she would be quiet if told "silence." The correction is specific, checkable and right. "Beginning of show" is loose timing but does not change the substance, and S25 went straight on to the point at issue.
Appeal this callout
Appeals come only from the debaters themselves. Sign in with Google to start; you'll then prove which debater you are, once.