Appeal: concession
From Debate MELTDOWN: Worst Opponent Yet: Austin Peterson Libertarian Debate Vs Jay Dyer.
- #7741:18:27upheld Austin Peterson epainos: concession (+1)
The council upheld the call: Austin Peterson earned 1 point.
“Yeah. Yeah. I agree. And I mean, like and and I so I wrestle with that. And I'll tell you, it's I think that, you know, it it it's it's difficult to live in a society where we can balance to or to create a society where there is a balance against those laws of nature.”
Diogenes: He grants the premise being used against him — that force is always operative in nature — and admits the tension it creates for his own position instead of resisting the setup.- Aristotle uphold: On the record: S1's stated openness to being shown wrong ("I could be wrong... willing to change my mind") is exercised here on a specific premise without abandoning his overall framework, consistent with rather than contradicting his standing position. Directly asked whether he agrees that "force wins" descriptively in nature, Austin plainly concedes ("Yeah. Yeah. I agree") and further acknowledges the resulting tension for building a rights-based society, rather than resisting or deflecting the premise being used against him — a clean concession.
- Socrates uphold: Read blind, found "concession". Asked to agree or disagree with Jim Bob's premise that "force wins" descriptively in nature, Austin explicitly concedes the point ("Yeah. Yeah. I agree.") and goes on to grapple honestly with what that concession means for constructing a civilized society, rather than resisting or deflecting.
- Plato uphold: On the record: S1 has stated throughout his willingness to be shown wrong and to wrestle honestly with challenges to his framework; this is a direct instance of that stated openness rather than a departure. Jim Bob's premise was that force always wins/looms in nature, and Austin explicitly agrees ("Yeah. Yeah. I agree") and acknowledges the resulting difficulty for constructing a rights-based society against that backdrop, rather than resisting or deflecting the premise — a genuine concession.
Appeal this callout
Appeals come only from the debaters themselves. Sign in with Google to start; you'll then prove which debater you are, once.